The ONS says UK car insurance prices rose 8% in the year to October, the fastest since mid-2024, while the ABI says the average premium paid was only 2% higher at GBP 562. We explain the gap and what EY's forecast of 12% rises in 2027 could mean.
Two official-looking numbers on UK car insurance are telling different stories. Consumer price data from the Office for National Statistics shows motor insurance prices up 8% in the year to October 2026, from 6% in September and the steepest annual rise since June 2024. Yet the Association of British Insurers says the average premium customers actually paid in the third quarter was GBP 562, only about 2% higher than a year earlier.
This PolicyRix Team analysis explains why the two differ, and which one a driver should pay attention to.
The numbers side by side
ONS motor insurance index: up 8% year on year in October, and up 1.3% in the month alone. It turned positive in December 2025 after a long slide that bottomed at minus 13.4% in March 2025. ABI average premium paid: GBP 562 in the third quarter, about 2% higher than a year earlier. Defaqto's measure of the most competitive quoted motor premiums: 2.7% higher at the end of September, the first annual rise since 2023.
On our arithmetic, the gap between the ONS and ABI measures is about 6 percentage points.
Why they differ
The ONS tracks the price of broadly comparable cover over time, closer to what a customer would see if they renewed the same policy without changing anything. The ABI averages what customers actually paid across many policies. That average is pulled down when drivers switch to cheaper insurers, choose higher excesses, drop optional extras or buy cheaper cover. In a rising market, the ABI figure tends to lag because people work harder to keep their bill down.
So a driver who renews without shopping around is more likely to see an increase close to the ONS figure. A driver who compares quotes and adjusts cover may see something closer to the ABI figure, or even a fall.
Why prices are rising
Claims are expensive. The ABI says insurers paid a record GBP 3.2 billion in motor claims in the third quarter, up 8% year on year, with the average claim steady at about GBP 4,900. Vehicle maintenance and repair prices rose 5.2% in the year to October in the ONS data. Consultancy EY expects motor insurers to pay about GBP 1.08 in claims and costs for every GBP 1 of premium in 2026, meaning an underwriting loss.
EY has pencilled in premium rises of 4% in 2026 and 12% in 2027. Applied to the ABI's GBP 562 average, our illustration suggests about GBP 584 after a 4% rise and about GBP 655 if a further 12% followed, an increase of about GBP 93 over two years. These are not forecasts for any individual driver.
Home contents is turning too
The ONS contents insurance index was still 5.3% lower than a year earlier in October, but that was the smallest fall since May 2025, and prices rose 1.2% in the month, the biggest monthly rise since May 2024. The overall ONS insurance index, covering motor, home, health and other cover, rose 4.7% to its highest level since the series began in 1988.
What drivers can do
Compare quotes three to four weeks before renewal, when prices tend to be lower than on the renewal date. Check that like-for-like cover is being compared, including the excess and courtesy car. UK pricing rules mean an insurer cannot charge a renewing customer more than a new customer with the same profile through the same channel, but other insurers may still be cheaper. Paying annually avoids interest on monthly instalments. Young drivers can look at telematics policies.
What the data cannot tell us
The ONS index measures price changes for representative policies, not individual quotes. The ABI average mixes many types of cover and drivers. Neither shows regional differences, which are large. And forecasts depend on claims costs, which can change quickly.
The short version: car insurance prices are rising again, faster than the average bill suggests, and drivers who shop around will feel the least of it.
Key Points
- 1ONS motor insurance prices rose 8% in the year to October, the fastest since June 2024.
- 2The ABI average premium paid was GBP 562 in Q3, only about 2% higher, a gap of about 6 points.
- 3The ONS tracks comparable cover; the ABI average reflects switching, higher excesses and cheaper cover.
- 4Motor claims hit a record GBP 3.2 billion in Q3; EY expects premiums to rise 4% in 2026 and 12% in 2027.
- 5The ONS overall insurance index reached its highest level since the series began in 1988.
Why This Matters
Most UK drivers renew every year. Understanding why headline figures differ helps them see that shopping around is the main way to avoid the full rise.
Understand the numbers
- GuideWhat Is a Combined Ratio? How to Read an Insurer's Earnings in Plain English
- GuideHow Auto Insurance Premiums Are Priced โ and 9 Legitimate Ways to Lower Yours
- CalculatorInsurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator ยท Compare a low and a high deductible using your own claim odds.
Related Stories
UK Ombudsman Sides With Customers in Half of Claim Delay Disputes
November 21, 2026
Ontario Approves Car Insurance Rate Cuts, but Quotes Are Still Rising
November 20, 2026
German Car Insurance: Prices Flatten Before the Nov 30 Switch Date
November 19, 2026
UK Inflation Hits 3.6%: What It Means for Savers and Tracker Borrowers
November 18, 2026
Daily Intelligence
The PolicyRix Daily Brief
Get the day's key insurance and finance stories in one email, each linked to its original source. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Informational newsletter only. Not financial advice. Disclaimer