🇺🇸 Mortgage Rates Hover Near One-Year Highs at About 7.4% as Inflation Data and the Fed Loom — Freddie Mac🇺🇸 Hurricane Isaias Makes Landfall on the Florida Panhandle as Insurers Begin Assessing Damage — Insurance Business🇮🇳 IRDAI Proposes Sweeping Caps on Insurance Commissions as RBI Weighs In — Business Standard🇮🇳 RBI Raises Repo Rate to 5.50% and Shifts to Calibrated Tightening as Oil and the Rupee Weigh — GKToday🇬🇧 Volkswagen Sets Aside £725 Million for UK Car Finance Redress as the Industry Bill Climbs — Insurance Journal (Bloomberg)🇦🇺 ASIC Tells General Insurers to Fix Premium Disclosure, Cash Settlements and Claims Management Firm Conduct — ASIC🇺🇸 Mortgage Rates Hover Near One-Year Highs at About 7.4% as Inflation Data and the Fed Loom — Freddie Mac🇺🇸 Hurricane Isaias Makes Landfall on the Florida Panhandle as Insurers Begin Assessing Damage — Insurance Business🇮🇳 IRDAI Proposes Sweeping Caps on Insurance Commissions as RBI Weighs In — Business Standard🇮🇳 RBI Raises Repo Rate to 5.50% and Shifts to Calibrated Tightening as Oil and the Rupee Weigh — GKToday🇬🇧 Volkswagen Sets Aside £725 Million for UK Car Finance Redress as the Industry Bill Climbs — Insurance Journal (Bloomberg)🇦🇺 ASIC Tells General Insurers to Fix Premium Disclosure, Cash Settlements and Claims Management Firm Conduct — ASIC
PR

PolicyRix

Insurance & Finance Intelligence

Free Tool

Insurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator

Compare a lower and a higher deductible using your premiums and realistic claim frequency to see which option costs less.

Cheaper option on your numbers

Higher deductible (saves ~$200/yr)

Premium saved per year (high ded.)

$300

Extra you pay if you claim

$1,000

Break-even

3.3 claim-free years

You could cover the higher deductible from cash on hand, so the cheaper-premium option is financially workable.

Estimates are for general education only and are not financial, insurance or tax advice. Calculations run in your browser; nothing you enter is sent to our servers.

What a deductible really is

A deductible is the amount you pay yourself on a covered claim before the insurer pays the rest. Choosing a higher deductible lowers your annual premium because you are agreeing to absorb more of the small losses. The trade-off is simple: you pay less every year, but more on the day something goes wrong.

The break-even idea

Subtract the lower premium from the higher premium to see how much you save each year by taking the higher deductible. Divide the extra deductible by that annual saving and you get the number of claim-free years it takes for the savings to pay for one claim at the higher deductible. If you expect to claim less often than that, the higher deductible usually wins; if you claim more often, the lower deductible is cheaper. The calculator also converts your own estimate of claim frequency into an expected annual cost for both options.

Be realistic about claim frequency

People tend to underestimate how often they will claim and overestimate how often they will use cover for small losses. Many drivers avoid claiming for minor damage anyway because a claim can raise future premiums, which makes a higher deductible even less costly in practice. For home and health insurance, consider that some claims — a burst pipe, an emergency admission — arrive in clusters.

The affordability test matters most

A lower premium only helps if you can actually pay the deductible. The tool compares the higher deductible with the cash you could find tomorrow; if the cash is short, the lower deductible is the safer choice even when the maths slightly favours the other. Some policies also have separate deductibles for specific perils (such as wind or hail) or percentage deductibles, so check the schedule on your own policy before relying on a single figure.

This is an educational estimate. Premiums and rules vary by insurer, product and country; always compare actual quotes. You can follow how regulators and insurers are changing pricing in our Insurance coverage.