Cotality links insurance nonrenewals to falling home values: in Dare County, North Carolina, 13% of policies were not renewed in 2023 and values fell about 10%. On a $400,000 home that is $40,000 of lost equity. We compare the US, Australian and storm-belt evidence.
Home insurance is usually discussed as a monthly bill. New research from property data firm Cotality argues it is becoming a driver of home values too. In its report "Weather rewrites home value," Cotality sets out cases where insurers pulled back after disasters and local prices followed.
This PolicyRix Team analysis puts the main figures on a common scale, converts them into equity on a typical home, and sets out what they do and do not prove.
The cases, side by side
Dare County, North Carolina: in 2023, 13% of property insurance policies were not renewed, and home values fell by about 10%. By 2025, price growth had turned negative.
Lake County, California: nonrenewals reached 7.6% in 2023 after repeated wildfire seasons, and Cotality says rising insurance costs are pricing some residents out.
Winkler County, Texas: about a quarter of homeowners dropped their cover, according to the report.
Naples, Florida: price growth fell by 8.3%.
Expressed per 1,000 insured homes, that is 76 nonrenewals in Lake County, 130 in Dare County and about 250 households without cover in Winkler County. Those are large numbers for a single year. For comparison, nonrenewal rates in most US counties are in low single digits.
What it means in equity
A 10% fall on a $400,000 home in Dare County is $40,000 of lost equity, before any change in the insurance bill. For many families, home equity is their largest store of wealth, so a fall of this size matters more than a premium rise of a few hundred dollars a year. It also affects mortgage lending, since lenders require insurance and a falling value can push a borrower's loan-to-value ratio above key thresholds.
Australia offers a longer view
Cotality's Australian data looks at recovery after floods. In Lismore, New South Wales, home values remain about 5% below their pre-flood level. In southeast Queensland, which also flooded but recovered faster, values are about 31% above pre-flood levels. Applied to a home worth A$600,000 before the floods, the Lismore figure implies about A$570,000 today and the southeast Queensland figure about A$786,000, a gap of roughly A$216,000. That is our illustration of the gap, not a valuation of any home.
Storms are spreading the problem inland
The report says about 9.5 million homes in the US Midwest are in counties where severe-storm risk is rising. In Kiowa County, Colorado, Cotality projects an extra $1.4 million of storm losses by 2040. Allianz has estimated that severe convective storms, which bring hail, tornadoes and damaging winds, caused about $60 billion of insured losses worldwide in 2025. These storms do not get the headlines of hurricanes, but they now drive a large share of homeowner claims, which is why insurers in states far from the coast are raising prices and deductibles too.
Denise Moore and Anand Srinivasan of Cotality argue in the report that the answer is resilience: homes built or retrofitted to resist local hazards keep their insurability and therefore their value.
What homeowners and buyers can do
Buyers should get insurance quotes before making an offer, not after, and ask the seller for the current premium and claims history. Owners in areas where insurers are pulling back should look at mitigation that insurers reward: impact-rated roofs in hail and hurricane zones, cleared defensible space in wildfire areas, and raised utilities in flood zones. Many states offer grants for roof upgrades. Keeping proof of upgrades can also help when shopping for cover or selling.
What the data cannot tell us
The report shows that nonrenewals and price falls happened together; it does not prove that one caused the other. Storm damage, local jobs and wider housing market moves also affect values. The county figures come from different years and different hazards, so they are not a ranking. Our dollar figures apply one percentage to a single example home. And recovery is possible: southeast Queensland shows that values can rebound strongly where rebuilding and insurance return.
The short version: in places where insurers retreat, the cost to homeowners is showing up not only in premiums but in the value of the home itself.
Key Points
- 1In Dare County, North Carolina, 13% of policies were not renewed in 2023 and home values fell about 10%.
- 2Lake County, California saw 7.6% nonrenewals in 2023; about a quarter of homeowners in Winkler County, Texas dropped cover.
- 3A 10% fall on a $400,000 home is $40,000 of lost equity on our calculation.
- 4In Australia, Lismore values are about 5% below pre-flood levels while southeast Queensland is about 31% above.
- 5Cotality says 9.5 million Midwest homes are in counties with rising severe-storm risk.
Why This Matters
For most families, home equity is their biggest asset. If insurance retreat drags values down, the cost of climate risk lands on owners twice: in higher premiums and in a lower sale price.
Understand the numbers
- GuidePercentage Deductibles Explained: Wind, Hail and Hurricane Cover
- GuideWhat Is a Combined Ratio? How to Read an Insurer's Earnings in Plain English
- GuideHow Much Home Insurance Do You Need? Replacement Cost vs Market Value
- CalculatorInsurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator ยท Compare a low and a high deductible using your own claim odds.
Related Stories
Who Should Refinance at 7.11%? Break-Even by Loan Vintage
November 18, 2026
Binance's $6.3bn Hack Shows How Little Crypto Theft Is Insured
November 18, 2026
Australian Home Cover Rises 6% as Rates Hit 4.85%: The Squeeze
November 18, 2026
Cowbell Launches Standalone Insurance for Damage Done by AI Agents
November 18, 2026
Daily Intelligence
The PolicyRix Daily Brief
Get the day's key insurance and finance stories in one email, each linked to its original source. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Informational newsletter only. Not financial advice. Disclaimer