A PolicyRix Team comparison of Lemonade, Root and Hippo's third quarters shows Root shrinking premium to stay profitable, Hippo growing 60% while keeping only about 30% of the risk, and Lemonade growing 34% while still losing money, as it keeps more risk for itself.
Five years after the big insurtech listings, the three best-known US digital insurers have settled on very different strategies, and their third-quarter 2026 results make the contrast unusually clear. One is giving up growth to protect profit, one is growing fast by passing most of its risk to others, and one is growing fast while taking on more risk and still losing money.
This PolicyRix Team analysis compares Lemonade, Root and Hippo using figures from their third-quarter results, as covered in our earlier stories and in reporting by Reinsurance News and Insurance Business. The ratios and changes marked as ours are our own calculations.
Root: profit by shrinking
Root, which sells car insurance, reported net income of $14.4 million against a loss a year earlier. Its gross combined ratio improved to 96.8% from 101.3%, meaning it now earns more in premium than it pays in claims and costs. But gross written premium fell 8% to $357.5 million, even though policies in force rose 4% to 484,037. On our calculation, premium per policy fell about 8.9%, to $1,441 from $1,581. The company said it deliberately gave up growth in its direct channel where expected returns fell below its threshold, and it has leaned on partners such as Carvana.
Hippo: growth with low retention
Hippo grew gross written premium 60% to $498 million and reported a combined ratio of 98.4%, against 99.6%. It also raised its full-year guidance. But net written premium, what it keeps after reinsurance, rose only 26% to $149 million. On our calculation, it retained about 30% of what it wrote, down from 38%. Hippo has also moved away from its roots: casualty business grew 146% and made up 38% of gross premium, while homeowners fell to 23%. Net income was $9 million.
Lemonade: growth while taking back risk
Lemonade's in-force premium rose 34% to $1.55 billion and revenue jumped 73% to $336.1 million. Most of the revenue jump came from keeping more of its own business: ceded earned premium, the share passed to reinsurers, fell to $69.3 million from $134.7 million, according to Reinsurance News, a drop of about 49% on our calculation. That means Lemonade now carries more of its own losses. The gross loss ratio rose to 65% from 62%, and to 63% from 56% excluding catastrophes. The net loss widened to $43.7 million, about 13% of revenue on our calculation, though adjusted EBITDA losses narrowed and the company guided to its first positive adjusted EBITDA quarter in the fourth quarter. Shares fell about 7% on the day of the results, according to Insurance Business.
What the three paths tell us
Our reading is that each company is answering the same question, how to make a digital insurer profitable, in a different way. Root is pricing for margin and accepting slower growth, which is the conventional insurance answer in a competitive car market. Hippo is acting partly like a platform, writing business and passing much of the risk to reinsurers and partners, which reduces volatility but also caps how much underwriting profit it keeps. Lemonade is betting that its pricing models are good enough to keep more risk, which raises both the potential reward and the exposure to bad quarters, such as the higher loss ratio this time.
What it means for customers
For car insurance buyers, Root's falling premium per policy is consistent with the broader softening in auto pricing this year, and with growth through partners that may offer quotes at the point of buying a car. For Lemonade customers, management said on its earnings call that it is taking rate increases where claim costs have risen, including pet insurance, which is now its largest line, so some renewals may cost more. For Hippo homeowners, the shift toward commercial and casualty lines does not change existing policies, but it shows where the company sees its future. In all three cases, policies are backed by licensed insurance carriers, and state insurance regulators oversee their solvency.
What the data cannot tell us
The three companies define key measures differently: Root reports gross and net combined ratios, Hippo a single combined ratio, and Lemonade loss ratios and adjusted EBITDA rather than a combined ratio. Their lines of business differ, so their ratios are not directly comparable. One quarter can be distorted by catastrophe losses or reinsurance changes, and Lemonade's investor day on November 17 may add new targets.
The headline is that the insurtechs are no longer judged only on growth. Root is profitable but smaller, Hippo is growing with others' capital, and Lemonade is still paying for scale.
Key Points
- 1Root earned $14.4 million with a 96.8% gross combined ratio, but gross written premium fell 8% and premium per policy fell about 8.9% to $1,441 on our calculation.
- 2Hippo grew gross written premium 60% to $498 million with a 98.4% combined ratio, while keeping only about 30% of what it wrote, down from 38%.
- 3Lemonade's in-force premium rose 34% to $1.55 billion and revenue 73%, helped by cutting ceded premium about 49%, but its net loss widened to $43.7 million.
- 4Lemonade's gross loss ratio rose to 65% from 62%, and to 63% from 56% excluding catastrophes, as it kept more of its own risk.
- 5The companies report different measures and lines, so their ratios are not directly comparable.
Why This Matters
Digital insurers now cover millions of US renters, drivers, pet owners and homeowners. How each balances growth, profit and risk shapes their pricing and stability, which matters to customers choosing between them and established carriers.
Understand the numbers
- GuidePercentage Deductibles Explained: Wind, Hail and Hurricane Cover
- GuideWhat Is a Combined Ratio? How to Read an Insurer's Earnings in Plain English
- GuideHow Much Home Insurance Do You Need? Replacement Cost vs Market Value
- CalculatorInsurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator · Compare a low and a high deductible using your own claim odds.
Related Stories
Who Should Refinance at 7.11%? Break-Even by Loan Vintage
November 18, 2026
Binance's $6.3bn Hack Shows How Little Crypto Theft Is Insured
November 18, 2026
Australian Home Cover Rises 6% as Rates Hit 4.85%: The Squeeze
November 18, 2026
Cowbell Launches Standalone Insurance for Damage Done by AI Agents
November 18, 2026
Daily Intelligence
The PolicyRix Daily Brief
Get the day's key insurance and finance stories in one email, each linked to its original source. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Informational newsletter only. Not financial advice. Disclaimer