A PolicyRix Team analysis of six European insurers and reinsurers finds the reinsurers had used roughly 40% to 74% of their 2026 catastrophe budgets by September, while AXA and Allianz, which carry more European hail and storm risk directly, took the heavier hit.
Every big insurer sets aside a budget for natural catastrophes before the year starts, and the third-quarter reports published since late October show something useful when those budgets are placed side by side. The reinsurers, the companies that insure insurers, mostly finished September well inside what they had planned for. The primary insurers that sell home and business cover directly in Europe had a much rougher summer, because the costliest events of 2026 were hailstorms and storms that land mainly on their own books.
This PolicyRix Team analysis compares six groups: Swiss Re, Hannover Re, Munich Re, SCOR, AXA and Allianz. The figures come from each company's third-quarter or nine-month results, as covered in our earlier stories and in reporting on Swiss Re's release of November 5. The budget usage percentages are our own calculations. Each company defines its budget differently, so the comparison is a guide to direction, not a precise league table.
How much of the budget was used
Swiss Re's property and casualty reinsurance unit reported large natural catastrophe losses of 640 million US dollars for the first nine months against a full-year budget of 1.6 billion dollars, according to Insurance Business. On our calculation that is 40% of the annual budget used after three quarters of the year, or about 53% of a simple pro-rata nine-month budget of 1.2 billion dollars. The main events were the earthquake in Colombia in August and Storm Kristin in Portugal in January.
Hannover Re reported large losses, which include natural catastrophes and big man-made claims, of 1,316 million euros for nine months against a pro-rata budget of 1,786.5 million euros. That is about 74% of the nine-month budget on our calculation, leaving roughly 470 million euros unused, and about 57% of the full-year budget of 2.3 billion euros.
SCOR reported a nine-month natural catastrophe ratio of 5.4% against a budget of 10%. In budget terms that is 54% used. Its third quarter was heavier, at 9.1%, so the year-to-date figure hides a busier summer.
Munich Re gives its budget as a share of revenue rather than a money amount. Major losses in the third quarter were 14.9% of net insurance revenue against the 18% it expected, which is about 83% of the quarterly budget on our calculation. The Colombian El Choco earthquake was the costliest single event at 300 million euros.
The primary insurers look different. AXA said natural catastrophe losses exceeded its prorated annual budget of 4.5 points of combined ratio, driven by secondary perils, mainly hail and storms in France, Switzerland and Italy. Allianz did not give a budget comparison in the figures we used, but natural catastrophes added 5.1 points to its third-quarter property and casualty combined ratio, against 0.3 points a year earlier, and Beinsure put the quarter's catastrophe claims at about 1.07 billion euros, most of it from European storms, hail and wildfires.
Why reinsurers were spared
Our reading, which is an interpretation rather than something the companies stated, is that the pattern reflects who carries which layer of risk. A hailstorm causes thousands of medium-sized claims across cars, roofs and windows. Each claim is small, and the insurer that sold the policy usually pays most of the total itself, because its reinsurance only starts paying once losses from one event pass a high threshold. Earthquakes and very large windstorms are the events that reach deep into reinsurance programmes. In 2026, the big European losses were the frequent, medium-sized kind, and the large single events were limited, so the burden fell on primary insurers.
There is a second reason. Reinsurers spent the past few years raising prices and the point at which their cover starts. Swiss Re's own figures show the effect of softer pricing now: its P&C reinsurance revenue fell 8.6% to 12.8 billion dollars for nine months, and its July renewals cleared at a net price decrease of 5.3%, according to a summary of its presentation. Even so, its nine-month P&C combined ratio was 77.3%, a very wide margin.
What it means for policyholders
For homeowners and drivers, the reinsurance numbers are an early signal rather than a bill. When reinsurers have a light year and their prices are falling, the cost of protection that home insurers buy usually eases at the next renewal, which for many European and global programmes is January 1, 2027. That can take some pressure off home premiums over time. Against that, the insurers that sell to households, such as AXA and Allianz, are paying more of the hail and storm claims themselves, and those costs tend to show up in pricing for the regions hit hardest. A household in an area that had repeated hail claims should not assume cheaper reinsurance will translate into a lower renewal quote.
What the data cannot tell us
The fourth quarter is not in these numbers, and it includes the end of the Atlantic hurricane season and European winter storms. Budgets are defined differently: Swiss Re counts large natural catastrophes, Hannover Re includes man-made losses, SCOR uses a ratio and Munich Re a quarterly share of revenue. The figures also span three currencies. Finally, budget usage says nothing about whether a company's prices are adequate for next year, which is what ultimately decides what policyholders pay.
The short version is that 2026 has so far been a year of many medium-sized weather losses rather than one huge event, and that shape of year rewards reinsurers and penalises the companies that sell cover directly to households.
Key Points
- 1Swiss Re's P&C reinsurance unit used about 40% of its 1.6 billion dollar full-year natural catastrophe budget in nine months, with losses of 640 million dollars, on our calculation.
- 2Hannover Re's large losses of 1,316 million euros were about 74% of its nine-month budget, leaving roughly 470 million euros unused, and SCOR's 5.4% catastrophe ratio was 54% of its 10% budget.
- 3Munich Re's third-quarter major losses were 14.9% of revenue against 18% expected, about 83% of the quarterly budget, with the El Choco earthquake its costliest event.
- 4AXA said hail and storm losses breached its prorated 4.5-point budget, and catastrophes added 5.1 points to Allianz's third-quarter combined ratio against 0.3 points a year earlier.
- 5Our interpretation is that frequent, medium-sized hail and storm losses stayed with primary insurers, while softer reinsurance pricing may ease costs at January 2027 renewals.
Why This Matters
Catastrophe budgets show where the year's weather costs actually landed. If reinsurers had a light year and prices are falling, home insurers' protection costs may ease, but the insurers selling to households absorbed the hail and storm claims themselves, which can keep premiums high in the regions hit hardest.
Understand the numbers
- GuidePercentage Deductibles Explained: Wind, Hail and Hurricane Cover
- GuideWhat Is a Combined Ratio? How to Read an Insurer's Earnings in Plain English
- GuideHow Much Home Insurance Do You Need? Replacement Cost vs Market Value
- CalculatorInsurance Deductible Break-Even Calculator ยท Compare a low and a high deductible using your own claim odds.
Related Stories
Australian Home Cover Rises 6% as Rates Hit 4.85%: The Squeeze
November 18, 2026
Cowbell Launches Standalone Insurance for Damage Done by AI Agents
November 18, 2026
Microsoft 365 Outage: Why Most of the Loss Will Stay Uninsured
November 17, 2026
Asia Insurance Prices Fall Again, but Not for Japan or Motor Cover
November 17, 2026
Daily Intelligence
The PolicyRix Daily Brief
Get the day's key insurance and finance stories in one email, each linked to its original source. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Informational newsletter only. Not financial advice. Disclaimer