With the average two-year fix at 5.97% and the average two-year tracker at 4.68%, a PolicyRix Team calculation shows a tracker borrower would need Bank Rate to rise about 1.3 points almost at once to pay as much as a fixer over two years.
UK borrowers coming off fixed deals this winter face a choice that looks unusual. After the Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% on November 5, the average two-year fixed mortgage rate stood at 5.97% at the start of November while the average two-year tracker, which moves with Bank Rate, was 4.68%, according to Moneyfacts. Normally a borrower pays a premium for a tracker's uncertainty. Right now the tracker is the cheaper product by more than a full percentage point, and the obvious question is what has to happen for that gap to close.
This PolicyRix Team analysis works through the numbers on an example loan. The rates are Moneyfacts averages reported by Moneyfacts and by the trade publication Mortgage Professional (MPA); the repayment figures are our own calculations using a standard repayment formula. They ignore arrangement fees, which vary widely and can change the answer for a smaller loan.
How fixed rates got here
The Moneyfacts average two-year fixed rate rose from 4.83% in January to 5.97% at the start of November, its highest since December 2023, and the five-year average reached 6.00%. The Moneyfacts Average New Mortgage Rate climbed to 5.89%, a three-year high. Lenders price fixed deals off swap rates, which reflect where markets expect interest rates to go, and Moneyfacts linked much of the rise to swap volatility and to lenders repricing ahead of the rate rise. In other words, fixed rates already include an expectation that Bank Rate will go higher.
The example: 200,000 pounds over 25 years
On our calculation, a 200,000 pound repayment mortgage over 25 years costs:
At 4.83%, January's average two-year fix: about 1,149 pounds a month. At 5.97%, November's average two-year fix: about 1,285 pounds a month. At 4.68%, November's average two-year tracker: about 1,132 pounds a month.
So a borrower who could have fixed in January and is fixing now pays roughly 135 pounds a month more, or about 1,626 pounds a year, for the same loan. And today's fixer pays about 153 pounds a month more than today's tracker borrower, which adds up to about 3,666 pounds over a two-year deal if the tracker rate never moved.
What would close the gap
We calculated the tracker rate at which the monthly payment matches the 5.97% fix. It is 5.97% itself, which means Bank Rate would need to rise by about 1.29 percentage points straight away and stay there for two years before the tracker cost the same as fixing. A slower path leaves the tracker ahead. In a scenario where Bank Rate rises another 0.25 points after six months and a further 0.25 points after a year, our two-year tracker total is about 28,042 pounds against 30,839 pounds for the fix, a saving of roughly 2,796 pounds. That scenario is an illustration, not a forecast.
For context on sensitivity, our formula puts each 0.25 point move at about 36 pounds a month on a 250,000 pound, 25-year loan, close to the 37 pounds Moneyfacts estimated for the November rise. On the 200,000 pound example, each quarter point is about 29 pounds a month.
What the Bank has said
The Bank of England's November decision was an 8-1 vote, with one member preferring a half-point rise. Governor Andrew Bailey said the increase should not be seen as the first in an inevitable long sequence of hikes, while the Bank projected inflation at about 5% by mid-2027. The next decision is due on December 17. Those statements cut both ways for a tracker borrower: the Bank is not promising a run of rises, but inflation is expected to climb before it falls.
What it means for borrowers
A tracker is cheaper today and would stay cheaper unless rates rise sharply and quickly. The trade-off is certainty. A fixed payment makes budgeting simple and protects a household that could not absorb a jump of a few hundred pounds a month if inflation surprised badly. Borrowers weighing a tracker should check whether the deal has early repayment charges, because some trackers allow switching to a fix later without penalty, which gives a way out if rates start rising faster than expected. Those with little headroom in their budgets may reasonably decide that paying for certainty is worth it.
What the data cannot tell us
Averages hide a wide spread: the best deals at low loan-to-value ratios are well below 5.97%, and borrowers with small deposits pay more. Fees are excluded and can add more than a thousand pounds. Our scenarios assume rate changes pass straight through to trackers, which is how most work, but terms differ. Nobody knows the path of Bank Rate, and markets can move swap rates and fixed pricing within days.
The arithmetic is clear on one point: at today's averages, the fixed-rate premium is large enough that it pays for a lot of future rate rises before a tracker loses out.
Key Points
- 1Moneyfacts put the average two-year fix at 5.97% at the start of November, up from 4.83% in January, while the average two-year tracker was 4.68%.
- 2On our calculation a 200,000 pound, 25-year loan costs about 1,285 pounds a month at 5.97%, 1,149 pounds at 4.83% and 1,132 pounds at 4.68%.
- 3A tracker borrower would need Bank Rate to rise about 1.29 points almost at once, and stay there, to pay as much as a fixer over two years.
- 4In an illustrative path of two further quarter-point rises, the tracker still saves about 2,796 pounds over two years before fees.
- 5The fix buys certainty; the figures exclude fees, and averages hide a wide spread by deposit size.
Why This Matters
Hundreds of thousands of UK borrowers must choose a new deal as fixes end. Knowing how far rates would need to rise before a tracker costs more than a fix turns a gut decision into a number a household can test against its own budget.
Understand the numbers
- GuideWhen Does Refinancing a Mortgage Pay Off? The Break-Even Explained
- GuideAPR vs Interest Rate: What Each Number Tells You About a Loan
- GuideHow Much House Can You Afford? Debt-to-Income Ratios Explained
- CalculatorMortgage Refinance Break-Even Calculator ยท How long a lower rate takes to repay refinancing costs.
- CalculatorMortgage Affordability Calculator ยท Estimate the home price your income and debts can support.
- CalculatorLoan & Mortgage Payment Calculator ยท Monthly payment, total interest and the effect of paying extra.
Related Stories
UK Inflation Hits 3.6%: What It Means for Savers and Tracker Borrowers
November 18, 2026
Who Should Refinance at 7.11%? Break-Even by Loan Vintage
November 18, 2026
Direct Line Home Cover Gets Higher Limits and Zero Emergency Excess
November 17, 2026
Ghost Brokers: One New Fake Car Insurance Network Found Every Day
November 17, 2026
Daily Intelligence
The PolicyRix Daily Brief
Get the day's key insurance and finance stories in one email, each linked to its original source. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Informational newsletter only. Not financial advice. Disclaimer